Furnished Apartments For Rent In Mystic Ct . Today's average rental price for two bedrooms here is $1,891. What are you looking for? 23 Judson Ave, Mystic, CT 06355 from www.realtor.com Old mystic furnished apartments for rent; Preview floor plans, view amenities. We provide a cost calculator, pricing tools, and more so you’ll know exactly what it will cost to live in the city you love.